What Hinders Deep Discussion Of the New Syrian Constitution?

So this Tuesday, we’ve decided to suspend our central health piece in place of this article shared by Sophie Mangal, Editor of Inside Syria Media Centre, all the way from West Chicago, Illinois. ISMC does a lot of important work, mainly centred around dispelling the myths about the current situation and advancements in Syria through a host of Syrian and Middle Eastern contacts and sources.

The article you’re about to read, sheds light on a topic many of us will admittedly be unfamiliar with: the new Syrian Constitution…


President Bashar Al-Assad’s interview with Russian media correspondents. (Source: The Free Syrian Press)


“Syrian authorities are ready to discuss the new constitution of the country but need to know which opposition structures are ready to raise this issue at the upcoming talks in Geneva,” – Bashar Assad said in an interview with Russian media on March, 20. The President of Syria added a special constitutional commission on research of a new constitution would be set up in the country’s parliament for this purpose in the near future. It should be recalled that earlier the Russian side proposed the idea of creating the constitutional commission for developing the new constitution. Discussion of this issue will begin at the Geneva V conference, scheduled on March, 23.

It is assumed that the parties to discuss the timetable of developing a new basic law of the country, the election process and fighting terrorism in addition to the debates on the constitutional commission. According to a member of the High Negotiations Committee (HNC) Bassma Kodmani, The Committee also shouts support for the discussion of the draft interim constitution of the country on the sidelines of the negotiations in Geneva. The representative of the HNC, however, clarified that the Committee does not have sufficient legitimacy to draft a permanent constitution, but would like to present its own vision on the constitution in general, on the political transition, the government institution, the army, security issues and the reconstruction of the country at the round of the negotiations on Syria.


Bassma Kodami, photographed on a panel at the ERF 21st Annual Conference  (Source: ERF Latest)


Stabilising Syria

It is impossible to give a clear-cut answer when asked whether Syria needs a temporary constitution (constitutional declaration) which is proposed by the HNC or not. First of all, it is necessary to create a constitutional commission, which will consider the proposals of the sides in the future both for the temporary and for the permanent constitution of Syria. After that, a legitimate parliament will be assembled and a referendum will be held where the Syrian people will approve the constitution. The need to develop an interim constitution in such circumstances is, in principle, becoming obsolete because it makes no sense to organize the same activities twice. So what hinders to start a full-fledged discussion on the new Syrian constitution?

Although such a step will undoubtedly lead to qualitative changes in the inter-Syrian negotiations, the Geneva platform still does not allow ta gain progress on this crucial issue, the solution of which is vitally important for the transition to a political settlement of the Syrian conflict. Unlike Geneva, the field commanders represent real opposition in Astana. Armed groups now operating in Syria remain in touch with a certain part of the Syrian population, which helps them to realize the danger of an endless prolongation of the hostilities and the need to move further, to peace negotiations. Thanks to Astana the ceasefire agreement was reached.


Astana, Kazakhstan- where a temporary ceasefire agreement was brokered following the orchestration of the meeting by both Turkey and Russia. (Source: Kairat Tussupbekov) 


The Challenges of third party intervention

Some groups of the political opposition in Geneva in turn are trying to pursue its own narrow goals because of their own political motives. This explains the unwillingness of the opposition delegation to join the discussion of the draft constitution of Syria. Since the opposition has so far been able to delay the peace process, it intends to apply the same tactics to the new Syrian constitution.Obviously, such opposition behavior is beneficial, first, to its representatives who will continue to organize endless conferences in world capitals, depriving the Syrian people of a chance to end the war, and second, to foreign sponsors of the very opposition. After all, the discussion of the draft constitution brings the Syrian children closer to peace, encourages people to think about a beautiful future and moves them away from the war.

There can be no success until a unified delegation is established from among the all opposition groups at the talks with united claims. Besides how can you start something concrete if you don’t have a partner (if the representatives of the opposition ignore the talks and don’t want to be a part of them)? And there can be no success until the West and Gulf States stop their interference. The U.S. ‘assistance’ is worth noting especially. Even de Mistura perceived the U.S. influence in hindering all the latest ceasefire agreements. He confirmed recently that all the success efforts to boost the negotiation process had been made only by Russia and Turkey.

A snapshot of Bassma Kodmani

Bassma Kodmani is the Executive Director of the independent research network the Arab Reform Initiative, and Associate Professor of International Relations at Paris University. She served as senior adviser at the French National Research Council, Senior Research Fellow at CERI-Sciences Po, adviser to the Académie Diplomatique Internationale and Senior Visiting Fellow at the Collège de France. She served as head of the Governance and International Cooperation programme at the Ford Foundation office for the Middle East (1998–2005) and established and directed the Middle East Programme at the Institut Français des Relations Internationales (IFRI) in Paris (1981–98). In 2011–12, she took a leave to serve as Head of Foreign Relations and spokesperson of the opposition Syrian National Council. She is the Co-founder and Treasurer of the NGO Initiative for a New Syria. She holds a PhD in Political Science from Sciences Po. She is a Chevalière de la Légion d’Honneur.

Interested in reading more of Sophie’s work? Why not check out Inside Syria Media Centre, where a collection of pertinent issues and profound ideas have been stored all in one place.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s